| | CITY OF EAST PROVIDENCE RHODE ISLAND JOURNAL OF REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING JULY 17, 2007 | |
The City Council meets in the Council Chambers on Tuesday, July 17, 2007 and Mayor Isadore S. Ramos calls the meeting to order at 7:30 P.M.
The invocation is read by Councilman DiTraglia and the Salute to the Flag is led by Mr. Richard Brown.
Lori Merolla from Merandi Reporting is present to record the proceedings of the public hearing.
| Present: | Mayor Isadore S. Ramos | | |
| | Robert E. Cusack | ) | Council Members |
| | Bruce DiTraglia | ) | |
| | Valerie A. Perry | ) | |
| | Bryan P. Silva | ) | |
| | | | |
| | Richard M. Brown | ) | City Manager |
| | William J. Conley, Jr. | ) | City Solicitor |
| | Virginia B. Nunes | ) | City Clerk |
I. CONSENT CALENDAR
A. APPROVAL OF COUNCIL JOURNALS
June 19, 2007 – Regular Meeting
B. LETTER OF RESIGNATION
Doreen E. Carter, Chair, East Providence Cancer Control Task Force
C. BLOCK PARTY – September 1, 2007
Roger Morrell, 16 Outlook Avenue (02914)
D. ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE-CLASS F – August 19, 2007
Cape Verdean Museum Exhibit, 1003 Waterman Avenue (02914)
E. ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE-CLASS F – July 29, 2007
Holy Ghost Brotherhood of Charity, Brain Lundstrom Memorial Motorcycle Ride, 59 Brightridge Avenue (02914)
F. CANCELLATION/ABATEMENTS (Requested by Tax Assessor)
| YEAR | AMOUNT |
| 2005 | $246.71 |
| 2006 | $1,857.68 |
| 2007 | $35,559.12 |
| | |
| Total | $37,663.51 |
On motion of Councilwoman Perry, seconded by Councilman Silva, and on a roll call vote, it is unanimously voted to approve the Consent Calendar.
II. APPOINTMENTS
1. Carousel Park Commission (by Councilman Silva)
Ernie Germani (for a term ending July 19, 2010)
35 John Street (02914)
On motion of Councilman Silva, seconded by Councilman DiTraglia and on a roll-call vote, it is unanimously voted to approve.
III. LICENSES REQUIRING PUBLIC HEARING
1. Additional Hours (All approvals have been met)
Tim Hortons New England, LLC d/b/a Tim Hortons, 25 Newport Avenue (02916)
Karen Larkin, 234 Taugwonk Road, Stonington, CT (06378) was sworn in by City Solicitor.
Mayor Ramos asked for Ms. Larkin to explain the request.
Ms. Larkin stated the additional hours would be from 2 a.m. to 6 a.m.
Councilman Silva asked so that would make it a 24 hour operation.
Councilman Cusack stated the previous occupant was Wendy’s and I know they were open very late. Do you know if they were 24 hours, I know they were beyond 1:00 a.m. it was over after 1:00 a.m.?
Ms. Larkin didn’t know.
Mayor Ramos wanted to know the hours for similar operations throughout the City.
Mr. Conley stated the Clerk could correct me we have a number of establishments open 24 hours.
Councilman DiTraglia asked if it would be open inside for the 24 hours.
Ms. Larkin stated yes.
No one wishes to speak.
On motion of Councilman DiTraglia, seconded by Councilwoman Perry and on a roll-call vote, it is unanimously voted to approve.
VII. LICENSES NOT REQUIRING PUBLIC HEARING
1. Hawker (Subject to approvals from the Chief of Police, Health Inspector, Zoning Officer, and City Manager)
Linda A. Souza, d/b/a L A S Snacks, 234 Forbes Street (02915)
No one is present.
On motion of Councilman Silva, seconded by Councilwoman Perry and on a roll-call vote, it is unanimously voted to deny.
2. Wrecker/Tower (Subject to approval from the Chief of Police)
David A. Reis, d/b/a Reis & Sons Service, 909 Wampanoag Trail (02915)
David Reis, 9 Cedar Lane, Seekonk, MA (02771) was sworn in by City Solicitor.
Mayor Ramos asked Mr. Reis to explain what you would like to do.
Mr. Reis stated he would like to tow for the City and was told he had to apply for this license with the City first.
Councilman Silva asked if he was fully insured.
Mr. Reis stated he is.
On motion of Councilman Silva, seconded by Councilman DiTraglia, it is unanimously voted to approve.
1. Gatherer (Subject to approvals from Chief of Police, Building Inspector, and Fire Marshall)
Karen Sweezey, 188 Waterman Avenue (02914)
No one is present.
On motion of Councilwoman Perry, seconded by Councilman Silva, it is unanimously voted to defer to the next meeting.
IV. LICENSING COMMISSIONERS RESUME SITTING AS CITY COUNCIL
V. CONTINUED BUSINESS
VI. NEW BUSINESS
A. CITY MANAGER’S REPORT
1. Automatic External Defibrillators
Mr. Brown stated there was an impressive turnout of employees being certified in CPR and Automatic External Defibrillators. Among us are three people who took advantage of that training and stand ready to assist, Bill Conley, Virginia Nunes and myself. We have 16 employees in the City hall; we ultimately would like to get all of our public buildings with certified personnel. We need another $16,000 to purchase equipment and asking Council to take this from the Rescue Fund.
On motion of Councilwoman Perry, seconded by Councilman Silva and on a roll-call vote, it is unanimously voted to approve.
Councilman Silva asked about two defibrillators that were never received by the state.
Mr. Brown stated he was sure the Fire Department would have picked them up.
Councilman Silva stated no they didn’t, at the time it was stated they could only to be used in the City hall and the last City Manager didn’t want to take the responsibility.
Mr. Brown stated he would look into it.
2. Project Agreement between City of East Providence and the Roger Williams University Institute for Public Policy
Mr. Brown stated we have had a number of discussions regarding consolidating the City and the School System. Efforts had stalled for one; the school committees had been undecided of the level of commitment. I have been informed that they have agreed that they will undertake an exploration of all areas in conjunction with the City. The other is trying to do this most economically as possible by keeping the study in house, perhaps we or I created an environment of distrust between the City and the School System. Their thinking that any study I did would naturally be bias in favor of one organization or the other because of what I do for a living. While I don’t agree with that, perhaps both the Superintendent and I are to close to this. We were approached by Roger Williams University Institute for Public Policy and they informed us that they would like to be involved with this effort. I discussed this with the Superintendent reviewed the memorandum of understanding with her and her only comment was she asked to be a signatory to this. This is not something that requires Council approval from a legal point of view, but I would like the Council to confirm that this is an appropriate action as we will spend some public money and a lot of effort to accomplish this endeavor.
Councilwoman Perry asked if any other group looked at this. I know the School Department was working with Education Partnership.
Mr. Brown stated the Education Partnership doesn’t do this kind of work they were focused on the contract issue. The School System has been working with Bacon and Edge looking at the School System itself and trying to generate effectiveness in the School System. The Roger Williams University would be looking at the commonalities or both organizations.
Councilwoman Perry asked if Mr. Brown had talked to the Superintendent about this.
Mr. Brown stated yes we put her name on the document.
Councilman Cusack asked does this Institute have any experience with consultant projects of this kind.
Mr. Brown stated that they had experience with consulting projects and with analysis but there hasn’t been a lot of work like this.
Councilman Cusack stated he looked at this $25,000.00 and asked if Mr. Brown had prices from comparable private cost.
Mr. Brown stated this is about ½ of the lowest price I’ve ever seen and the fifty or so thousand was an organization that was probably less complex than the one we’re talking about now.
Councilman Cusack stated the time on this project is twelve months.
Mr. Brown stated Roger Williams was hoping to do the initial draft at the end of December. I asked that the contract be structured for a year because I don’t believe that they will be able to meet that and I didn’t want to have to modify an agreement.
Councilman Cusack asked if he was comfortable with the length of time of this contract.
Mr. Brown stated it’s ambitious.
Councilman DiTraglia asked how did there resume look.
Mr. Brown stated these are professors associated with the Institution with Public Policy.
Councilman DiTraglia asked if they have been involved with this before.
Mr. Brown stated they have been involved in management studies they haven’t been in studies like this and the reason is there haven’t been studies like this.
On motion of Councilwoman Perry, seconded by Councilman Silva and on a roll-call vote, it is unanimously voted to approve.
3. Tax Stabilization – Igus Bearings, Inc.
Mr. Brown stated one of the first rules in economical development in order to grow your economy is to take care of the businesses you have in town and that’s the case of what we’re present tonight. Igus Industries has been located in East Providence about 20 years and they are moving to a new location on Ferris Avenue and they are building approximately a 98,000 square foot $5 million facility in order to help them realize this project, by the way these are manufacturing jobs, they are asking for a tax stabilization they meet with the City economic development commission as a result they have agreed to except a 10 year tax stabilization on that property.
Mayor Ramos stated I would like to see something added on to that. I agree with you and I agree we have to give large companies a tax break but someway the City has to be protected. Say 10 years down the line and they decide to move out of that place. I assume that the taxpayer get a break but I know the banks put an addendum in it and it they move to another state the taxpayer should be due the tax that is due. I would like to see a protection to the taxpayers.
Mr. Brown stated we do have protection in a couple of areas. This company has a history in East Providence and rather than looking outside the City for their expansion they did opt to stay here. The second is the building that they are constructing is close to $5 million so if they decide to leave we have the ability to put that building on the tax rolls of East Providence at full market value, but anticipating that concern we did have a discussion with Igus and they have agreed that they will accept a means of protection along the lines that you have suggested. If Council gives me the authorization we can work out the specific language, because I don’t want to delay this proposal. We go back with the Director of Planning, the City Solicitor and myself and revisit the tax stabilization ordinance and try to put that language in to the ordinance itself.
Councilman Cusack stated it’s less expensive for industrial to move to urban area. Looking at the numbers the bottom line is if we weren’t doing stabilization we would be getting $900,000 tax revenue because of the stabilization we would be getting $400,000 instead of $900,000 so we’re giving them about $500,000. If they were to leave they own that building, but if you could work out a plan as a fall back if they leave it would revert to a full evaluation. I want to be competitive.
Councilman DiTraglia stated I think it’s great big business coming into the City but make sure you have some good backing and don’t forget the small business have been here have been keeping our tax rolls going.
Councilman Cusack stated this has been one of those good businesses that operate from around the corner from where I live.
On motion of Councilwoman Perry, seconded by Councilman Silva and on a roll-call vote, it is unanimously voted to approve with stipulation.
4. Automated Collection Expenses
Mr. Brown stated Mayor Ramos asked for information about automating our refuse collection system. I asked Steve Mutter to update a report that he presented to you over a year ago. It would require an investment of over $2 million dollars on our part. I’m presenting this information for our planning purposes with the budget I couldn’t recommend that we go ahead with this but only recommend we receive this for the record and keep this in mind for the next couple of years.
On motion of Councilman Cusack, seconded by Councilman Silva and on a roll-call vote, it is unanimously voted to accept this as information purposes.
5. IBPO Contract Negotiations
Mr. Brown stated he does not have the information at this time and would like this defer to the next meeting.
On motion of Councilwoman Perry, seconded by Councilman DiTraglia and on a roll-call vote, it is unanimously voted to defer to the next meeting.
Mr. Brown had two announcements. First on July 19, 2007 at 5:00 p.m. in room 306 there will be a presentation on the reuse of the Bomes Theater. The other announcement is the City of East Providence in conjunction with the Rhode Island Department of Health wants to be sure our residents would be protected in a public health emergency. We’re having eight pods with pointed distributions of medical supplies drill. We need 200 volunteers to assist us at the Martin Middle School, Wednesday, August 1, 2007 at 7:00 p.m. – 8 p.m. Although we block an hour the approximate time would be between 15 or 20 minutes. Please pre-register at the City hall at 435-7766 and we will have tokens of appreciation for those who volunteer.
B. REPORTS OF OTHER CITY OFFICIALS
CLAIMS COMMITTEE (by William J. Conley, Jr. – City Solicitor)
Mr. Conley stated the claims and litigations report of July 17, 2007
| Jane Brosnihan Claim No. 07-026 | | Approved the claim in the amount of $675.09 |
| Mark Carter Claim No. 07-027 | | Approved the claim in the amount of $991.05 |
| Marie Corbie Claim No. 07-029 | | Refer to the Law Department |
| Jeanne Holmes Claim No. 07-028 | | Approved the claim in the amount of $1,553.40 |
| Sean LaFramboise Claim No. 07-031 | | Approved the claim in the amount of $175.00 |
| Joyce Mariano Claim No. 07-030 | | Approved the claim in the amount of $993.84 |
| Ronald Nawrocki Claim No. 07-025 | | Approved the claim in the amount of $380.19 |
| Karen Krahulik Claim No. 07-022 | | Approved the claim in the amount of $1,095.00 |
Finally from June 19, 2007 the Council will recall that we recessed the claims committee and reported everything out in the regular meeting and then concluded the regular meeting went back into claims committee and we had one more claim.
Michael J. Damiani vs. City of East Providence Refer to the Law Department
On motion of Councilman Silva, seconded by Councilwoman Perry and on a roll-call vote, it is unanimously voted to approve.
Mayor Ramos stated you do a great job and I was very pleased the way you handled City business at our special meeting. I felt so comfortable up here with your guidance to the Council which you portrayed to protect the interest of the City and I want to thank you publicly for that.
C. COUNCIL BUSINESS
1. Raise the Salary Harbormaster – S. Bruce Dufresne from $9,000.00 to $12,000.00 (by Councilman DiTraglia)
Councilman DiTraglia wanted to call up Mr. Dufresne so people can be aware of what’s going on for the record.
S. Bruce Dufresne, 10 Lunn Street, (02915) was sworn in by City Solicitor.
Mr. Dufresne stated in April 2003 I was appointed to take over as Harbormaster. The Department was in a deficit of $23,000 the records were in a milk crate, boats wouldn’t pass CG inspection, we got no respect from boating public and there was a law suit pending. The actions I took was immediately stopped the deficit spending. Paid the general fund in full, computerized the records. I purchased a computer myself. Applied and was awarded $222,000 in grants to replace boats. Most recently $56,250 grant for a pumpout boat. We earned the respect of the Marina Operators who now donate $10,000 in services. I held an annual fundraiser for the last 4 years and earned over $10,000. State law mandates training of 6-8 days a year and HM’s perform MSD Inspections. Any vessel who has a marine toilet has to be inspected by the HM went into effect last year. I inspected 100 vessels it takes about one hour per inspection that’s 100 hours to my work load. In addition I did 11 mooring inspections the total of those inspections added 116 hours to my work load, but brought in $3,600.00 in income to the department. This year I’ve done 70 inspections. If you recall the audit he mentions the enterprise account has never been in better financial condition. It is finally being run like a business or corporation. We are an enterprise account. I don’t get one penny of that account for my salary. My budget I earn the money that I bring in with moorings, fines, inspections and donations. We have close to 1000 boats at Bullock Cove. We have 300 moorings in 8 mooring fields and developing a 9th. HM’s are uniformed, attend training and conduct themselves in a professional manor. This takes a lot of time and a lot of regulation we have meetings with the Coast Guard all around the state I don’t get a City vehicle I drive in my vehicle. The Harbor Commission in the City has recognized the effort I have put into this job in a timely efficient and professional manner I promised to the City Council that appointed me and to the Harbor Commission that I would straighten out the problems and bring it into the 21 century in a professional manner. In June 2006 the Harbor Commission voted unanimously to increase my stipend from $9,000.00 to $12,000.00 that was funded last November 1 and to go into effect last November 1. The last month’s Harbor Commission meeting approved my budget for 2007 – 2008 which again calls for the same amount my stipend that was approve to go into effect and will be funded this November 1. I respectfully request that you reconsider my request to raise my salary.
Mayor Ramos stated I don’t believe this Council took a vote not to raise your salary and I believe that the City Manager, I, Mr. DiTraglia and others have been discussing it. There are some legal ramifications that we have to look at before we can do that.
Mr. Brown stated part of this is ordinance changes, the other is the result of some of the reports that you’ve given me. The position was appointed by Council you are an independent contractor, the Council does not assign work hours conditions or supervisor the manner in which you conduct your work, but there are some activity for which you’ve received additional compensation and you and I have had some discussion on that and until we can resolve that I’m not sure we can act on the request.
Councilman DiTraglia stated the Harbormaster has done a wonderful job. You see the record he has done. We have to take into consideration we have waterfront property development coming and we need the Harbormaster Commission and the Harbormaster to keep our water looked at regularly. We need to act on this as quick as we can. I know there are some issues we need to resolve these as soon as we can. I think in another 10 years we’ll be adding another boat. This is a self sufficient department that’s running very well now and we need to keep it running.
Mr. Brown stated that Mr. Dufresne should check with the Army Core of Engineers because he heard this morning that they are putting off the dredging of the Bullock Cove for another year.
Councilman Cusack stated he wanted to thank Councilman DiTraglia for bringing this forward this is new to me. I don’t know what Richard has or the additional compensation, but this is an impressive record and I want fair compensation for the Harbormaster for what he’s accomplished.
Mayor Ramos stated I am also impressed with Mr. Dufresne’s presentation and what he’s accomplished. No one at this point said he wouldn’t get a raise. From my understanding there are some things that he and the City Manager have to work out.
Councilwoman Perry stated I used to take care of the mooring slips and half of what was supposed to be in the clerk’s office was missing. Mr. Dufresne took everything and came back with it organized. I was impressed. Over the years the reports that come out of there are professional and I’m very pleased that we have him. He does a very good job and I will do anything to support him.
Councilman Silva said you stated that the slips are no charge. Is that the pumpout boats the fire boats. When did this happen.
Mr. Dufresne stated after I was appointed they started calling and I started taking care of their problem and they stopped charging us for that and I got them to donate 3 boat slips and the fire boats as well.
Councilman Silva asked if any boats were kept on Pier Road.
Mr. Dufresne stated yes at the East Providence Yacht Club.
Councilman Silva asked if that was a donated slip.
Mr. Dufresne asked the fire chief.
Chief Klucznik stated it is not donated slip.
Councilman Silva stated I was under the impression that someone else donated a slip. Is it required to be there?
Mr. Dufresne stated for practicality purposes we keep a fire boat which Station 1would respond and Riverside Station 2 for the other end of the City. Levin’s Marina, Cove Haven’s Marina, everything in Bullock’s Cove is donated.
On motion of Councilman DiTraglia, seconded by Councilman Silva and on a roll-call vote, it is unanimously voted to defer to the next meeting.
D. RESOLUTIONS
1. The following Resolution in Support of Justice for Janitors.
RESOLUTION IN SUPPORT OF JUSTICE FOR JANITORS
WHEREAS, contracted janitors who clean commercial office buildings in East Providence are diligent and hardworking men and women; and
WHEREAS, many of these contracted janitors work for wages and benefits that keep them below the poverty level; and
WHEREAS, many of these contracted janitors do not earn enough to afford healthy food, decent housing, health care, a college education, or the chance for a better life; and
WHEREAS, janitorial contracting services are part of a volatile industry in which contracted janitors lose their jobs with little or no notice; and
WHEREAS, many of these contracted janitors have begun to organize for wages and benefits that will support them and their families and not require that they work two and three jobs to make ends meet; and
WHEREAS, all contracted janitors should be free to join with their co-workers to organize and better their working and living conditions without threats or intimidations.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the City Council for the City of East Providence urges all cleaning contractors who do business in East Providence to pay their employees a living wage, to provide decent health benefits, and to allow their workers to have a voice on the job and urges building owners in East Providence to ensure that contractors who clean their buildings pay their employees a living wage, provide decent health benefits, and allow their workers to have a voice on the job.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the City Council for the City of East Providence joins with numerous religious, civic, and labor organizations in expressing their support for the dozens of East Providence janitors who are struggling to improve their working conditions and provide their families with a living wage, decent health benefits and a voice on the job.
This resolution shall become effective upon its passage. (Requested by: Mayor Ramos)
On motion of Councilwoman Perry, seconded by Councilman Silva, and on a roll-call vote, it is unanimously voted to dispense with the reading of the resolution.
Councilman Cusack stated I believe this organization Justice for Janitors dispute is private we have no roll in employees and employers. We wish all the parties happiness and fairness and private negotiations and I would not be in favor of this.
Councilwoman Perry stated I agree with Mr. Cusack I don’t think this is something the City Council should be involved in. I don’t think we should dictate what other companies are doing.
Mayor Ramos stated the reason I put it on here is it doesn’t hold the City binding to anything other than the fact that everyone should be treated fairly.
On motion of Councilman Silva, seconded by Councilman DiTraglia and on a roll-call vote, it passes 3 – 2.
Councilman DiTraglia, Councilman Silva and Mayor Ramos voted aye.
Councilman Cusack, Councilwoman Perry voted nay.
2. The following Resolution Authorizing the Financing of a Design Build Heating System at East Providence High School through a lease purchase agreement not to exceed one million six hundred thousand dollars ($1,600,000.00).
RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE FINANCING OF A DESIGN BUILD HEATING SYSTEM AT EAST PROVIDENCE HIGH SCHOOL INCLUDING THE REMOVAL AND REPLACEMENT OF AN OIL TANK THROUGH A MASTER LEASE AGREEMENT OR LEASE PURCHASE AGREEMENT IN A PRINCIPAL AMOUNT NOT TO EXCEED ONE MILLION SIX HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS ($1,600,000) AND AUTHORIZING THE EXECUTION AND DELIVERY OF A MASTER LEASE AGREEMENT OR LEASE PURCHASE AGREEMENT AND RELATED INSTRUMENTS, THROUGH THE RHODE ISLAND HEALTH AND EDUCATIONAL BUILDING CORPORATION AND DETERMINING OTHER MATTERS IN CONNECTION THEREWITH
WHEREAS, the City desires to finance a design build heating system at East Providence High School including the removal and replacement of an oil tank (the "Project") pursuant to a master lease agreement or lease purchase agreement (the "Lease"); and
WHEREAS, the City Council initially approved the Project and the financing on December 5, 2006; and
WHEREAS, the Project is essential for the City to perform its governmental functions; and
WHEREAS, City desires to take the necessary steps to arrange for the acquisition of the Project.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that:
l. The City Council hereby authorizes the Mayor and the Finance Director acting on behalf of the City, to take the appropriate steps to undertake the Project and to finance the same through the Lease and related documents, including but not limited to an escrow agreement, in a principal amount not to exceed One Million Six Hundred Thousand Dollars ($1,600,000) (the "Financing Documents"), subject to annual appropriation therefore by the City.
2. The Financing Documents may include provisions for financing the Project through the Rhode Island Health and Educational Building Corporation Public Schools Bond Program.
3. The form and other details, terms and conditions of the Financing Documents shall be fixed by the Mayor and the Finance Director.
4. The Mayor and Finance Director are hereby authorized to enter into the Financing Documents and said officers are hereby authorized and instructed to take all actions, and to execute and deliver the Financing Documents and any related agreements, certificates and other documents in such form as they may deem necessary or desirable to implement the lease purchase financing of the equipment. Such officers are also authorized to take all action, on behalf of the City, necessary to insure that interest component of the lease payments will be excludable from gross income for federal income tax purposes and to refrain from all actions which would cause the interest component of the Lease to become subject to federal income taxes.
5. That this Resolution is an affirmative action of the City Council of the City toward the execution and delivery of the Financing Documents in accordance with the purposes of the laws of the State. This Resolution constitutes the City's declaration of official intent, pursuant to Treasury Regulation 1.150(2), to reimburse the City for certain capital expenditures paid on or after the date which is sixty (60) days prior to the date of this Resolution, but prior to the execution and delivery of the Financing Documents. Such amounts to be reimbursed shall not exceed $1,600,000 and shall be reimbursed not later than eighteen (18) months after (a) the date on which the expenditure is paid or (b) the date the property is placed in service or abandoned, but in no event later than three (3) years after the date the expenditure is paid.
This Resolution shall take effect upon its passage.
On motion of Councilwoman Perry, seconded by Councilman Silva, and on a roll-call vote, it is unanimously voted to dispense with the reading of the ordinance.
Mr. Brown stated he believes Council has already approved this and this is just a rewriting of this.
Mr. Conley stated the Council had approved this project in December 5, 2006 we are now at the financing end of the project and the Treasury requires that the entity with the bonding authority approves but the financing needs to be approved and only the Council has the authority to approve the bind the financing.
On motion of Councilman Silva, seconded by Councilwoman Perry and on a roll-call vote, it is unanimously voted to approve.
E. INTRODUCTION OF ORDINANCES (If given First Passage, can be referred to the next regular Council Meeting to be held on August 21, 2007 for a public hearing and consideration of final passage).
1. The following is an ordinance amendment regarding stop sign at Ray Street (eastbound and westbound traffic) at Barney Street.
AN ORDINANCE IN AMENDMENT OF CHAPTER 18 OF THE
REVISED ORDINANCES OF THE CITY OF EAST PROVIDENCE,
RHODE ISLAND, 1998, AS AMENDED, ENTITLED
“VEHICLES AND TRAFFIC”
THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF EAST PROVIDENCE HEREBY ORDAINS:
SECTION I. Sec. 18-269 entitled “Stop and yield intersections designated; when stops required.” is amended by adding thereto the following:
RAY STREET (eastbound and westbound traffic) at Barney Street
SECTION II. This ordinance shall take effect upon second passage and all ordinances and parts of ordinances inconsistent herewith are hereby repealed. (Requested by: Director of Public Works)
On motion of Councilwoman Perry, seconded by Councilman Silva, and on a roll-call vote, it is unanimously voted to dispense with the reading of the ordinance.
On motion of Councilwoman Perry, seconded by Councilman DiTraglia and on a roll-call vote, it is unanimously voted to approve.
2. The following ordinance amendment regarding “Administration” of Chapter 2.
AN ORDINANCE IN AMENDMENT OF CHAPTER 2 OF THE
REVISED ORDINANCES OF THE CITY OF EAST PROVIDENCE,
RHODE ISLAND, 1998, AS AMENDED, ENTITLED “ADMINISTRATION”.
THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF EAST PROVIDENCE HEREBY ORDAINS:
SECTION I. Article III entitled “Boards, Committees, Commissions” of Chapter 2 of the Revised Ordinances of the City of East Providence, Rhode Island, 1998, as amended, entitled “Administration” is amended by adding thereto the following:
Division 13. Canvassing Authority.
Sec. 2-206 A. Meetings.
(a) The chair of the Canvassing Authority shall have the authority to call regular meetings and special meetings may be called by the City Council, the chair or any two (2) members of the board, provided that written notice shall be given to all members.
The board shall meet at regular intervals throughout the year but at no time shall such meetings be less than four (4) times per year. The first meeting of each year shall take place no later than March 31, the second meeting no later than June 30, the third meeting no later than September 30, and the fourth meeting no later than December 31 of each year. Such meetings shall be scheduled after the close of normal business hours.
(b) The Canvassing Authority shall also meet at such other times as may be required by Title 17 of the General Laws of the State of Rhode Island.
SECTION II. This ordinance shall take effect upon its second passage and all ordinances or parts of ordinances inconsistent herewith are hereby repealed. (Requested by: Councilman Cusack)
Councilman Cusask stated the reason I’m presenting this ordinance amendment is simply to bring the canvassing authority in concurrence with many of our other boards who have a minimum number of meetings per year and to have the meeting at night to facilitate the attendance of the public like we are doing tonight. I don’t want to belabor it; I beg my Council colleagues would allow this to move forward and a month from now we could take a look at this and have the time to do so by this first passage. This is to insure that the canvassing authority does meet four times a year and any other time that two members should request. There’s kind of a fairness act here. The canvassing authority is a majority and a minority, if indeed if there is no minimum number of meetings, the majority could defer for an unlimited amount of time. I would remind on a Federal level the rules of the Congress in charge their very careful because they know they may not be in charge so they want to make sure things are fair.
Councilman DiTraglia stated I’m not sure if we are overstepping our bounds on this. The canvassing board, they must have their rules and we get involved with this I’m sure they must have so many meetings a year the time is set by the chairperson. I’m not sure but most boards and commissions have their regulations that they go by, maybe they follow the Board of Elections or Secretary of State office. Before we go ahead and do any of this I think we should look into this before we overstep our bounds.
Mr. Conley stated the statuary requirements in Title 17 do have two mandates for meetings. Those meetings revolve around election schedules and the voter certification. Statuary required around the election and voter certifications other than voter rolls and election results there are not any other mandates.
Councilman Cusack asked if we would be overstepping our authorities and would it conflict at all.
Mr. Conley stated this was actually one of the issues that was looked at the other evening we have a accession of state government function, we do have to be careful we don’t have the same degree of control over that type board like our own local boards and commissions, however, that doesn’t mean you’re without the authority to implement rules and regulations. I stated the other evening that they had not chosen to regulate some of the schedule meetings but again a requirement of the meeting is not a recipient of the mandate. I would be more concerned if the council was trying to regulate attempt to impose inconsistent with the requirement with the mandated time of Title 17 that would be a problem. Mandate meeting over the course of an annual period should not interfere with the mandated meetings.
Councilman DiTraglia stated wouldn’t it be advised that you I’m sure the canvassing board didn’t know anything about this. Why not Mr. Brown or even you sit down with the canvassing board and say this was brought up at the council meeting what other input do you have. After all it is their department; we’re standing up here not even asking what they would like. Personally I would be a little upset if I didn’t have any input in this. I would like the department themselves to look this over.
Councilman Silva stated I think our City Charter clearly left this out because this is regulated by the state. Last week we were accused of crossing the line that we shouldn’t involve ourselves in state election laws. How can five elected officials change the law? Is this another one of those stunts of a political party who wishes to micro manage a department? I don’t think that’s what we should do in my opinion its micro managing a department. If you read those emails in one of them said she was going to schedule a meeting. I don’t think they’re giving a person or a department a fair chance to prove that there going to straighten a department up. I think this is a specific particular political group and special interest group to micro manage a department.
Mayor Ramos stated he agreed with Mr. Silva and the boys in the back can laugh all they want that their prerogative and you’re not going to back door this Council. We made the changes up there and you haven’t even given the people a chance to reorganize their office.
Councilman Cusack stated I am the source of this ordinance other people in this room are not the source of it. You might find it remarkable but I am the source of it all by myself. I felt there was a dispute there is no other agenda. I saw our annual report on this beautiful calendar and all these months with meetings for various boards and commissions. We know when they are being held ahead of time. Are we micro managing those particular boards and commissions? I know when the next city councils going to be. I think on a state level the idea was to be sure that business gets done around election time and many years ago that may have been sufficient I think now even on off years there are issues that people want to bring forward. I ask only that we could have a full hearing a month from now and have this first passage.
On motion of Councilman Cusack, seconded by Councilwoman Perry, and on a roll-call vote, it is denied 2-3.
Councilman Cusack, Councilwoman Perry voted aye.
Councilman DiTraglia, Councilman Silva and Mayor Ramos voted nay.
E. COMMUNICATIONS
1. Vijali Anctil, President, RI Sri Chinmoy Centre, 33 Arthur Avenue (02914) was sworn in by City Solicitor.
Ms. Anctil stated she is requesting to name a street after the founder of our center Sri Chinmoy in honor of his 75th birthday it true he’s not a resident, but the center has been in East Providence for over 15 years. Since 1987 we have been part of the International Harmony Run which is in 70 to 80 Countries throughout the World and across the United States and we organize the Rhode Island segment of that run. I have given you all of the information with some of the activities to create harmony and peace in the World. This is part of what we do in our Meditation classes. If you feel you can’t rename a street after Sri Chinmoy than if we could put a sign under the street sign we would be happy with that.
Councilman Silva asked if you have a particular street.
Ms. Anctil stated no in 1991 there was a dedication of a bridge on Roger Williams Avenue with Mayor Sullivan. He’s been in Rhode Island several times he’s given lectures at Brown University.
Councilman Silva stated he understood but he needs to know where.
Ms. Anctil stated I’ll take suggestions Arthur Avenue is where the center is located.
Councilman Silva asked isn’t that where Four Season Apartments are located?
Ms. Anctil stated yes.
Councilman Silva asked is that a private street or a public street.
Ms. Anctil didn’t know.
Councilman Silva asked does the apartment complex have any problem with not changing but subtitling that name.
Ms. Anctil stated I didn’t ask I wanted to come to you first.
Councilman Silva stated you have to go the highway or planning department first but without knowing where or the size we can’t.
Mayor Ramos stated also you have to be concerned about the neighbors.
Mr. Brown stated he would advise council not to approve anything tonight and when she comes up with some different plans to bring them to my office and I will make sure they are routed to the appropriate department to review and if necessary we will come back.
Ms. Anctil asked and you are.
Mayor Ramos stated Mr. Brown he is the City Manager.
2. Charles Mello, Jr. 596 Willett Avenue (02915) was sworn in by City Solicitor.
Mr. Mello stated I chose a topic for tonight and I just saw something happen that unbelievable was denied first passage. Councilman Cusack raised this issue and the calendar has all the other meetings of committees. Last Thursday night I and others attended a special city council meeting involving Tom Riley member of our board of canvassing. This special meeting took almost 3 ½ hours for the Council to reach a decision that three of the members had long decided and publicly spoke about at the previous Council meeting when the charges were first introduced. The narrative spent 3 ½ hours on this meeting which eventually turned into a censuring of Mr. Riley could have been time better spent on something more constructive for all of us in East Providence instead of trying to please a few of those who were hoping for his removal. For instance when is this council going to have public meetings regarding the sewage plant and the cost of all of us? Renovations cost will be over $50 million dollars and that doesn’t include interest involved with the bonds necessary for such an undertaking which may bring the long term cost to $100 million or more. These costs are all necessary for our City to bring into compliance with DEM and a court order of which we are under for our City to come up with a financial plan by December 31, 2007. I hear no discussion. What will happen if they don’t come up with this plan? We will have penalties and fines. The budget plans are coming up shortly. They continue not having public meetings on these matters. Isn’t it time instead of spending 3 ½ hours on a hearing for Mr. Riley we could get the publican ball in a 1 hour 2 hour 3 hour meeting where the public could ask questions as far as which direction the City is going to take. I think its time the public demands meetings on this very important subject.
Councilman Silva asked to approach the City Manager with this piece of paper that I found on the back table and I would like to address it. I thought it was our public policy that we do not solicitant any political in here and if that is true I would like a written notice to this organization that this is not accepted in our City I don’t believe we’re suppose to be doing this. There is a pile on the back table.
Mr. Brown stated he would deal with this later.
3. Bob Carlin, 66 Merritt Road (02915) was sworn in by City Solicitor.
Mr. Carlin stated I’m chairman of EPGOP the past few years I have been observing the canvassing board and we have had documented voter fraud in our City. Our current chairperson as well as our last chairperson saw fit to do nothing about it. We have asked for meetings time and time again. We have seen nothing. Mayor Ramos says give her a chance. She’s been there 5 months how much more of a chance does she need. Mr. Cusack tried to put first passage of an ordinance. Mayor Ramos stated he would not be back doored by us. I don’t think anybody is being back doored by anybody I think we’re just being steam rolled. We need leaders to do something about the sad situation of the canvassing board and canvassing office. This proves further tonight that the Council has no intent of doing anything about the canvassing problems in this City. I won’t stand for it. I won’t be back doored. You had a hearing for email from Tom Riley. We haven’t had meetings for 5 months, where is that hearing. It’s not like we haven’t had major problems in the past we’ve had voter fraud in this city we have had 100 more ballots than we had voter’s signatures in the last election. We need to clean up this City we need to get fair honest open elections we need the City Council to back the people. I read this ordinance on the agenda and I thought this is really great now they would have to have meetings so we can bring forward complaints and questions. You just voted it down it’s only first passage. Are you not for fair and open elections? Why would you vote down this ordinance?
Mayor Ramos stated you’re not the savior of the City. There’s nobody up here that doesn’t want fair and open government. What I’ saying to you is you ask us to make changes in that office. We put a new chairperson in there we put a new member in there and you haven’t given them a chance to operate.
Mr. Carlin stated 5 months.
Mayor Ramos stated they weren’t in there 5 months.
Mr. Carlin stated Mrs. O’Gara has been there 5 months.
Mayor Ramos stated we put someone up there just recently so they weren’t up there for 5 months.
Mr. Carlin stated another stalling tacked.
Mayor Ramos stated you talk then I’ll wait till you finished.
Mr. Carlin stated we can have a dialogue. We can’t have a dialogue.
Councilman Silva calls for a point of order. This is public comments, Mr. Carlin made his statements and you made your statements it’s over after that.
Mr. Carlin stated oh really.
Mayor Ramos stated yes. I gave you an opportunity to address me and I don’t have a problem with that but I don’t want you to get up here and let all the taxpayers think that you’re the savior of the City because you’re not. We think about the same thing you think of as a Republican.
Mr. Carlin stated I disagree.
Mayor Ramos stated maybe you disagree maybe we look at thing differently then you do.
Mr. Carlin stated I look at actions the actions there haven’t been any.
Mayor Ramos stated I’m not going to discuss it with you again but I’m willing to listen to you. You made your comments. You asked us to make changes up in the office and we did. We haven’t even completed the task we just put someone there recently and now you’re in demand because the only thing you have to argue about in the City right now other than having Mr. Mello come up every meeting ranting.
Mr. Carlin stated my name is Bob Carlin.
Mayor Ramos stated I’m just making a comment to you I understand who you are. You’re the same individual who came to me when I talked about not having Mr. Larisa come in here you’re the same individual who walked up to me to say you’re absolutely right I agree with you.
Mr. Carlin stated and when I do agree with you I will say it.
Mayor Ramos stated and you’re the same individual who said to me that you wrote an article about me in the paper and you were going to rewrite that article. I haven’t seen anything yet.
Mr. Carlin stated I did but I can’t control what they print.
Mayor Ramos stated secondly we’re willing to work with you or anybody else in this City, but we’re not going to have you dictate to a board when they’re going to hold they’re meetings. They know when they’re going to hold they’re meetings. They’re setting it up right now. That board is going to do some work. Give them a chance. If you come back here in 2 months and say nothing is done you have a right to make the complaint. Give them a chance.
Mr. Carlin stated I appreciate your opinion Mayor but I think 5 months is enough.
4. Bill Murphy, 27 Wetmore Avenue (02915) was sworn in by City Solicitor.
Mr. Murphy stated he’s speaking as a taxpayer and a concerned citizen of the East Providence Citizens Groups. These three organizations have a common position and hope we could have a dialogue. We feel Mrs. O’Gara violated a public trust and failed to properly execute the official responsibilities by ignoring the request to have meetings to look into allegations of voter fraud we felt that was improper conduct in the canvassing office. One thing I’m hearing about people who complain about Mrs. O’Gara need to give her a chance. I’m surprised given six or seven requests to hold meetings complaints of voter fraud in the City in addition each one of those communications sited state laws Title 17 that were violated. The three organizations basically are asking that the Council would express sense that Mrs. O’Gara’s conduct in ignoring all of these is not appropriate conduct nor is it consistent with the public input. Secondly we would ask to express a sense that requesting the Canvassing Authorities fullest and open meetings as soon as possible and maybe schedule evening meetings after that. Thirdly we ask the City Council to remain open to discussion of future meetings and we hope in the next week or so to present a plan of recommendations that we think can help reduce some of the suspicion, controversy and animosity that’s been plaguing the process. One of the reasons the people are so upset is the system is not working. The citizens that have complaints have been denied the right to be heard. How can that be so bad to let people come forward and make their complaints? If there is no merit they will appear publicly and be dismissed if there is merit appropriate actions will be taken.
Mayor Ramos stated I don’t have any problems with what you say working together. I think it’s inevitable to resolve a problem. I can’t go into Mrs. O’Gara’s mind say what I think she should or shouldn’t have done. She’s the Chairperson I don’t know the circumstances I wasn’t there all I know is that Mrs. O’Gara, Mr. Riley and Mr. Barilla to me is going to do a great job up there. Given the opportunity of all the areas you’re talking about and the concerns of this community I don’t believe there is anyone up there that doesn’t have the same feelings that you have, I have, and that Mr. Riley has or anybody in this room. 1. We want to make sure the list is correct. 2. We want to make sure everyone has a fair vote the process in their voting. Those are the things we’re concerned about. Someone comes up there and makes statements like WE ARE and WE DEMAND to me that doesn’t bring anything to fruition. We have to work together.
Mr. Murphy stated I agree with you but all these letters that were being denied by Mr. Riley that’s not a very good way to do business.
Mayor Ramos stated I agree with you, but I don’t agree with that way of doing business because something isn’t right me personally I don’t believe someone should be harassed or any kind of demeanor anything in that nature. I agree with you and I don’t want anyone to accuse me of not doing due process so I was very careful of that.
Mr. Murphy stated it didn’t seem that.
Mayor Ramos stated I can understand where you’re coming from when you’re sitting over there with t-shirts on. We had to listen to the facts.
Mr. Murphy stated it seemed like you had your minds made up.
Mayor Ramos stated you had your mind made up when you walked in.
Mr. Murphy stated that’s my prerogative.
Mayor Ramos stated you did.
Mr. Murphy stated yes, but I wasn’t in charge a judicial procedure.
Mayor Ramos stated absolutely and I had to do it and I sat here and I hold to my decision that I made. My motion, it failed. The second motion passed, fine. But I’ll tell you something sir because of my own inner feelings because of how I feel about people and I asked every single person how would you feel if that was said to your mother, your sister anybody and not one person said it would be ok.
Mr. Murphy stated I understand that, it’s over.
Mayor Ramos stated that’s resolved now and we have to move forward to a positive thing to make sure we do what you’re saying.
Mr. Murphy stated it didn’t seem like tonight’s vote was the first step.
Mayor Ramos stated he is only speaking for himself I don’t want to demand anybody to do something that they haven’t had the opportunity to work out in the first place telling them when to hold meetings I don’t think that’s right.
Mr. Murphy stated Councilman Cusack spoke eloquently other boards are regulated.
Mayor Ramos stated I personally don’t want to regulate this board and I kept my views. We have Democrats and Republicans we have the same concerns that everyone in this City is treated fairly and equitably in the voting and anything else.
Mr. Murphy stated then the bottom line is you feel it is acceptable and appropriate not to have meetings…..
Mayor Ramos stated please don’t put words in my mouth.
Mr. Murphy stated for professional colleagues can ignore each other….
Mayor Ramos stated please I’m a professional please don’t put words in my mouth.
Mr. Murphy stated it is your opinion if colleagues ignore each others official communications about business that would be acceptable.
Mayor Ramos asked is that what you’re saying.
Mr. Murphy stated I’m inferring.
Mayor Ramos stated oh your inferring you can infer anything you want.
Mr. Murphy asked would you clarify it for me.
Mayor Ramos stated no I’m not going to clarify it anymore. I told you my personal feelings.
Mr. Murphy stated you didn’t answer my question.
Mayor Ramos stated I’m sorry.
Mr. Murphy asked Councilman Cusack.
Councilman Cusack stated colleagues should answer one another. The open meetings act allows one exception to email between members of the canvassing board. [A] The chair asks for a meeting. [B] The chair response or blast out to other members for a meeting. So it is permitted. So Mr. Riley’s emails could have been answered. They were the cause of a lot of frustration we dealt with the matter of the frustration but we haven’t dealt with the source of the frustration. So yes people should answer one another when the subject is the scheduling of meetings.
Mr. Murphy asked Councilman DiTraglia.
Councilman DiTraglia stated no I told you no earlier. It should be up to the board to set the rules. They could go by those dates, but it’s up to them. You have a group here that’s really concerned about the canvassing authority. What make you so upset about what’s going on in the canvassing authority?
Mr. Murphy stated it simple I’m a citizen that has serviced in the military who believe in the right to vote and the fundamental form of democracy that the system should have one vote and that only people who live in the district are doing this. The stories and the evidence I’m seeing is suggesting there’s a perpetual constant tendency to frustration the publics ability to get information to clarify issues to what’s going on and to making someone cynical and suspicious to what’s going on.
Councilman DiTraglia stated in other words you’re blaming the 2 women and Mr. Riley is 100% right.
Mr. Murphy stated oh no, right about what.
Councilman DiTraglia stated about everything Mr. Riley can’t do anything wrong.
Mr. Murphy stated I don’t think that’s true.
Councilman DiTraglia stated that’s what you’re saying that’s what everyone in this group is saying you’re saying Mr. Riley is doing everything right.
Mr. Murphy stated in terms of his discharge of public responsibilities I absolutely believe that he’s taken position on principals making sure the public should have access, if public raise complaints they should be able to air them. Also he is calling for disciplined professional process address leaning voter list.
Councilman DiTraglia asked do you think we are the only one in the state having problems.
Mr. Murphy stated I don’t but what’s the point...
Councilman DiTraglia stated it takes time to clean up the voters list.
Mr. Murphy stated I do but why can’t we talk about it and acknowledge the problem.
Councilman DiTraglia stated that like in September 2004 someone moved to another city and he did business here and his personal life got all messed up that could have been handled in the canvassing board that didn’t have to go outside.
Mr. Murphy stated I believe they were stonewalled. After repeatedly requesting then they went to the state police.
Mayor Ramos stated we have to move on we could be debating here all-night.
5. Bob Enos, 11 Milburn Road (02915) was sworn in by City Solicitor.
Mr. Enos stated I am upset that Mr. Cusack’s ordinance didn’t pass. At times we are all politically motivated. I would hope that you as a committee would be non partisan and vote for the betterment of the taxpayer, the citizens and the students. I believe with this not passing the Democrats except for one person Valerie and even Bob voted for the Party. I’m the President of the League of Concerned Voters which is a non partisan political group. Our main goal is to educate the taxpayers and citizens of the City. We are here to communicate our thoughts as a group. We all understand that the City Council had to protect the interest of their employees and appointees. Once a charge was made against Mr. Riley you had to conduct an investigation then follow the procedures. By doing this you at least prevented one law suit. My purpose today is to review the impact of Mr. Riley’s hearing of July 12, 2007. I stand before you not to change the past but improve the present. Mr. Riley wrote for number one hold more frequent meetings also to hold these meetings at a time the citizen could attend and to make sure our voter lists are accurate. If you don’t have an accurate voter list people who are willing to run can be screwed. This does not make Mr. Riley a bad citizen or a poor board member. Mr. Riley was considered a problem child right from the start from this community. He was the odd man out that no one was going to listen to. This and other frustrations led to his colorful emails. One of the allegations was if you received the emails you were a Republican. The other thing is the lack of order which was held within the chambers of this council. We had people yelling and screaming. Some of the remarks were pointed at Mr. Riley, but he couldn’t really answer. Mr. Riley and Mr. Larisa were held to address the emails. Finally if this was a true hearing for Mr. Riley to see whether Mr. Riley was in fact guilty it amazes me how many people had a predetermined result before the hearing. You can break it up into Democrats and Republicans and you could tell how the vote was going but if it wasn’t for one individual Mrs. Perry breaking through lines of Party support Mr. Riley would be guilty. I’m not here to defend Tom or anyone else, but this is a man who’s been fighting for what he believes is right as in anybodies right in this room has the right of free speech whether it is written or oral. Yes and rightfully so Mr. Riley’s emails were in bad taste however the true problem of what has taken place still isn’t solved and that is we have not had a canvassing board meeting since January. I really have two questions. When is the next canvassing board going to meet?
Mayor Ramos stated that’s the chairs position and I can’t answer that. When she determines when that meeting will be I’m sure she’ll notify us as most organizations do.
Mr. Enos stated can you ask her or any of the other members I know Peter I know Riley.
Mayor Ramos stated I’m going to get into that I’m not going to start cross examining the chairman.
Mr. Enos stated I’m not asking you to do that there hasn’t been a meeting since January.
Mayor Ramos stated this is communications you’re informing us of that.
Mr. Enos stated and my final, speak of meeting, have the school department members and yourself and Mr. Brown had a meeting this month about staffing.
Mayor Ramos stated Mr. Brown made a presentation earlier and he stated what he was doing in regards to that.
Mr. Enos stated I heard Mr. Brown but there were four people who were supposed to have meetings on staffing, one the Superintendent of School, the Chairperson of the School Committee, Mr. Brown and you. My question to you is have you people had a meeting.
Councilman Silva called for a point of order. I thought this was about Canvassing Authority how did we jump to the School Department.
Mr. Enos stated in your point of view and I will not get upset but that was brought up tonight so I decided to ask a question.
Mayor Ramos stated point of order.
Mr. Enos stated if I’m breaking point of order I apologize but there’s no need for you to yell at me.
Councilman Silva stated well maybe you couldn’t hear me and I wanted you to hear me.
Mr. Enos stated let me tell you when I get a hearing aid I’ll let you know. It’s your attitude that’s created a problem and when you keep talking like that you show how professional you are.
Councilman Silva stated put it on the docket for another day.
Mr. Enos stated if I’m breaking point of order.
Councilman Silva called point of order is that what’s on the topic sir.
Mr. Enos stated you attacked me.
Councilman Silva stated I didn’t attack you.
Mr. Enos stated oh yes you did. You people can not represent a party and vote with your heart.
Mayor Ramos asked Mr. Conley the hearing was interrupted by cheers and jeers and we banged the gavel and informed everyone we would have people removed. I don’t think the meeting was out of control. I want to make sure we met everyone’s legal rights for that hearing.
Mr. Conley stated I am fully confident that you met all the requirements of due process both under state and federal law and met all the standards provided for by the ordinance. I’m fully confident.
Councilman DiTraglia stated this said tonight extra party taxpayers groups anyone who calls Mr. Riley’s emails colorful belong right with Mr. Riley. Now how the canvassing board he should be working with them. The people of the canvassing board aren’t out to screw anyone. When I went canvassing house to house for votes I found and I marked on my paper when I was running any differences. Help the board of canvassers. In 2004 at the time of the prosecutions for voter fraud there was never any evidence of any wrong doing or irregularities by the East Providence Canvassing Board. I don’t know where you’re getting your information you make it worse there are no complaints on file in East Providence nothing on record now stop and get off your high horse start getting the canvassing authority in order. Now I talked to the Board of Elections today and the Secretary of State’s office there is no wrong doing in the City of East Providence. You laugh your making such a big circus you should be ashamed of yourself. This is what we’re looking to work together there not there to screw anyone. There doing there job.
Councilwoman Perry stated I heard Republicans and Democrats I understood this was a non partisan council. We never stop this political baloney we’ll never get anywhere.
Mayor Ramos stated I’m a Democrat and I’m registered and I’m doing it non partisan. I’m doing it non partisan just like you’re an Independent and your doing it non partisan.
IX. ADJOURNMENT
On motion of Councilman Silva, seconded by Councilman DiTraglia, it is voted to adjourn.
Mayor Ramos adjourns the meeting at 10:05 p.m.
Attest:
_________________________________
Virginia B. Nunes
City Clerk
Approved: August 21, 2007